• 33 ideas
  • Checked October 2026

What to Eat with Pumpernickel Bread

Cream cheese and smoked salmon, pastrami with mustard, liverwurst and onion, and a hollowed loaf full of dip.

What to Eat with Pumpernickel Bread

Show all 33
  1. Cream cheeseSpread it thick. The bread is strong enough to take it.
  2. Pastrami with mustardPile the meat warm and spread the mustard on the bread.
  3. Smoked salmon with capers and red onionButter or cream cheese first, then the salmon in loose folds.
  4. Liverwurst with red onion and mustardThick slices, thin onion, and mustard on the top slice of bread.
  5. Pickled herringDrain the fish well and lay it on buttered bread.

Next step See what else goes with pickled herringPick a bread to bake

All 33 ideas

Butter, cheese and spreads 9

  • Aged Gouda Shave it thin over buttered bread.
  • Blue cheese and pear Crumble the cheese and lay thin slices of pear on top.
  • Butter and sliced radishes Overlap the slices and finish with flaky salt.
  • Chopped liver Spread it on small squares and top with a little raw onion.
  • Cream cheese Spread it thick. The bread is strong enough to take it.
  • Havarti A mild, creamy slice for anyone who finds the bread strong.
  • Quark with chives Stir in the chives and a pinch of salt, then spread.
  • Salted butter A thin slice of bread and a thick layer of cold butter.
  • Strong, pungent cheese with sliced onion Small squares of bread, a slab of cheese and a ring of raw onion.

Smoked and pickled fish 6

  • Caviar Small buttered squares and a small spoonful on each.
  • Pickled herring Drain the fish well and lay it on buttered bread.
  • Smoked salmon with capers and red onion Butter or cream cheese first, then the salmon in loose folds.
  • Smoked sprats Two on a buttered finger of bread, with a slice of lemon.
  • Smoked sturgeon Slice it thin and add only a squeeze of lemon.
  • Whitefish salad A generous spoonful on a toasted slice.

Deli meats and sandwich fillings 4

  • Egg salad Good on a soft slice, with cress or lettuce.
  • Liverwurst with red onion and mustard Thick slices, thin onion, and mustard on the top slice of bread.
  • Pastrami with mustard Pile the meat warm and spread the mustard on the bread.
  • Tomato and raw onion slices Butter the bread, salt the tomato and eat it open.

Dips for cubes of it 4

  • Cheddar cheese ball Let it soften on the table, then spread it on torn bread.
  • Dill dip Stir it the day before so the dill comes through.
  • Spinach dip in the hollowed loaf Cut the scooped-out bread into cubes for dipping.
  • White bean dip Toast the cubes first so they hold the dip.

Soups and plates it goes beside 4

  • Kale and sausage stew Tear the bread and push it under the broth.
  • Oxtail soup A dark, rich soup that suits a dark, dense slice.
  • Potato pancakes with applesauce A slice of bread next to the pancakes, or underneath one.
  • Split pea soup with bacon Butter a slice and lay bacon or cheese on it.

Sweet things 3

  • Apple butter Spread it over butter or cream cheese.
  • Cherries and cream with pumpernickel crumbs Crumble a stale slice over the top for crunch.
  • Plum butter Thick and tart, best on a buttered slice.

Drinks 3

  • Hot malted milk A warm mug with a buttered slice in the evening.
  • Peppermint tea A clean, cool cup after smoked fish or strong cheese.
  • Strong black coffee A cup with an open sandwich, morning or afternoon.

How it works

What to eat with pumpernickel bread? The dark rye loaf is dense and strong, so it carries salty, smoky and sharp things well. These 33 ideas cover spreads, fish, deli meats, dips, soups and sweet toppings.

Read the full guide

What do you eat pumpernickel bread with?

Thin slices make tea sandwiches, with smoked salmon and cream cheese or with egg salad. Weisslacker, a pungent German cheese, is served on small slices with sliced onion. In the Netherlands, where the bread is known as Frisian rye, pea soup customarily comes with a slice and bacon, cheese or butter. German potato pancakes may be served with pumpernickel as well as applesauce.

What to eat pumpernickel bread with at a party

A round loaf with the middle cut out is a bowl for a cold dip, and the bread taken out of it is cut up for dipping. Spinach dip is the well-known filling.

  • Slice a dense loaf thin. A thick slice overpowers whatever is on it.
  • Toast the soft deli kind lightly, and leave the dense German kind as it is.

Questions and answers

What do you eat with pumpernickel bread for breakfast?

Cream cheese or salted butter, with smoked salmon, capers and red onion if there is time. For something sweet, apple butter or plum butter, and strong black coffee.

What cheese goes with pumpernickel?

Cream cheese and quark with chives for spreading, aged Gouda or Havarti in slices, and a strong cheese with raw onion. Blue cheese with pear suits small squares.

What sandwich is good on pumpernickel?

Pastrami with mustard, or egg salad. Liverwurst with red onion and mustard is a North American favorite on rye breads, and smoked salmon works open or closed.

More tools

Show 8 more

Browse Food